Three Mitchell baseball players accused of rape ask for transfer to juvenile court

By Mitchell Now February 7, 2024 6:03 am

clipart.com

RAPID CITY, SD (MITCHELL NOW) Three of the six Mitchell Post 18 American Legion baseball players accused of rape in Pennington County are set for a transfer hearing in July. The Rapid City Journal reports that the hearing will determine whether their cases are moved behind closed doors to juvenile court.

Last summer, the state alleged two 16-year-old victims were assaulted between June 1 and June 4 while the team visited Rapid City for a baseball tournament.

In an August 2, 2023 indictment, a Pennington County grand jury officially charged 18-year-old Hudson Haley, 17-year-old Karter Sibson, 18-year-old Carter Miller, 18-year-old Lincoln Bates, 17-year-old Peyton Mandel and 19-year-old Landon Waddell with second-degree rape and aiding and abetting second-degree rape against one of the alleged victims.

Haley faces an additional count of second-degree rape against the alleged second victim, and Waddell faces a count of aiding and abetting second-degree rape against that same victim.
On Tuesday, Circuit Court Judge Robert Gusinsky granted Sibson, Miller, and Mandel’s requests for a transfer hearing. He set the hearing for July 1 and July 2.

At that hearing, the young men’s defense attorneys will argue that the cases should be heard in juvenile court. In South Dakota, minors who are over 16 and charged with a class A, B, C, 1 or 2 felony are tried in adult court. Second-degree rape is a class 1 felony, automatically placing the minor’s cases in adult court.

The other three defendants — Haley, Bates and Waddell — are scheduled for a status hearing on July 1. Both the defense attorneys and the state agreed it would be best to await the outcome of the transfer hearing before setting a trial date since all six of the teenagers are codefendants.

In Davison County, two Mitchell Baseball Association board members face criminal charges for allegedly knowing about the crimes and failing to report them to law enforcement. Luke Norden, 43, of Mitchell, is charged with two counts of intentional failure to report the abuse or neglect of a child and two counts of misprision of a felony. The charges stem from June 27, 2022 and June 22, 2023. Jeremy Borgan, 48, of Mitchell, is charged with one count of intentional failure to report the abuse or neglect of a child on June 19, 2023.

Norden and Borgan both pleaded not guilty, and their cases are ongoing.

(Rapid City Journal)

Lifestyle

6 hours ago

Bird Flu Outbreak Hits South Dakota Turkey Flocks

South Dakota is facing a major bird flu outbreak, with more than 135,000 turkeys destroyed at three facilities to contain the spread. North Dakota has also reported cases, losing over 60,000 turkeys in commercial flocks. Agriculture officials stress that poultry products remain safe to eat despite the outbreak.

Government

7 hours ago

AG Marty Jackley Launches Campaign for Congress

South Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley has officially entered the race for Congress, launching his campaign in his hometown of Sturgis. Jackley, now in his fourth term as Attorney General, joins State Senator Casey Crabtree in the Republican primary to replace Congressman Dusty Johnson, who is seeking the governor’s office. Highlighting his conservative record, Jackley says he will prioritize public safety, border security, economic growth, and accountability in Washington while continuing to serve as AG.

Crime

6 hours ago

Huron Contractor Sentenced for Defrauding Customers

South Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley announced that Huron contractor Julio Morales-Ortiz has been sentenced for defrauding seven customers out of more than $36,000. Morales-Ortiz pleaded guilty in Beadle County Circuit Court to theft by deception, receiving a suspended 10-year prison sentence, probation, and jail time.

Government

6 hours ago

Freedom Caucus Pushes Back on $650M Prison Plan

South Dakota lawmakers will meet in a special session to decide on a proposed $650 million men’s penitentiary in Sioux Falls, but members of the Freedom Caucus remain opposed. While Lieutenant Governor Tony Venhuizen, who led the prison task force, says he’s confident in the plan’s passage, caucus members fear the price tag could balloon to $1 billion. Governor Rhoden’s office maintains the project is capped at $650 million.

Government

6 hours ago

Mitchell Plans Second Fire Station to Speed Up Response Times

Mitchell city officials are proposing a $2.5 million fire station on the north side of town to improve emergency response times and reduce insurance costs for residents. The station would be built near the old water treatment plant on Highway 37, with design work beginning in 2026 and an opening planned for 2027. City leaders say the new location will allow firefighters to reach the north side more quickly, while housing four firefighters who will share equipment with the current Public Safety building.